Which Garage Door is Best For You?

Choosing Between Wood, Steel, and Contemporary Garage Doors: What’s Right for Your Home?

Your garage door isn’t just a functional part of your house—it’s one of the first things people notice from the street. Whether you’re replacing an old door or picking one for a new build, choosing the right material and style can boost your home’s curb appeal, efficiency, and overall value. The most popular choices? Wood garage doors, steel garage doors, and contemporary garage doors. Here’s a simple guide to help you compare them.

Wood Garage Doors: Classic and Customizable

Wood garage doors are a timeless option known for their natural beauty and charm. They add warmth and elegance to any home, especially if you love traditional or carriage-style architecture. Wood doors can be customized in many ways—from panel design to stain color—giving you a one-of-a-kind look.

Pros:

  • Rich, natural appearance

  • Highly customizable

  • Great for traditional or high-end homes

Things to Consider:

  • Wood doors do best with a little regular maintenance, like painting or staining, to preserve their natural beauty.

  • They may cost more upfront, but the visual impact can be well worth it.

  • Since wood is a heavier material, installation may require a bit more care.

Steel Garage Doors: Durable and Budget-Friendly

Steel garage doors are a popular pick for good reason—they’re strong, low-maintenance, and cost-effective. These doors hold up well against the elements and are available in a wide range of styles and finishes.

Pros:

  • Durable and secure

  • Minimal maintenance

  • Great value with lots of design flexibility

Things to Consider:

  • While very sturdy, steel can dent under impact, though many styles include reinforced panels to help avoid this.

  • Proper coatings and finishes prevent rust, making it easy to keep your door looking fresh year after year.

  • Some homeowners prefer the look of wood, but steel doors can be designed to mimic that appearance beautifully.

Contemporary Garage Doors: Sleek and Modern

For a clean, minimalist look, contemporary garage doors are the way to go. These often feature materials like frosted glass, aluminum, or flush steel panels, and work well with modern and mid-century architecture.

Pros:

  • Stylish, modern appearance

  • Great for custom homes or remodels

  • Often includes unique materials like glass or metal

Things to Consider:

  • Depending on the materials, contemporary doors can be on the higher end of the price range.

  • Glass options may have slightly less insulation, but insulated glass and frame upgrades can solve that easily.

  • These doors are about style, so they’re perfect if you’re going for a bold architectural statement.

Which Garage Door is Best for You?

Whether you’re drawn to the warmth of wood, the strength of steel, or the sleek design of a contemporary garage door, the right choice comes down to your home’s style, your budget, and how much upkeep you’re comfortable with.

Need help deciding? At Carriage Door Utah, we install and service all types of garage doors. Contact us today for a free consultation and let’s find the perfect fit for your home.

 

Two ways to register for our Garage Door Maintenance Program:

Register online: Warranty Registration Form
Call us: 801-282-5001
Regular maintenance will generally significantly reduce overall repair costs!